The Middle Market Review Insights on the Middle Market.

Subscribe Subscribe

Subscribe Today

Please provide valid email address

I want to receive:

Thanks for subscribing!

CEOs

Recapitalizing for ROI

Tags

Most business owners understand that an exit strategy should include maximizing their return on investment (ROI). What does this mean and how can we accomplish this?

In the Part 1 of this two-part series we will be taking a look at achieving ROI through recapitalization. Read on to learn more about the basic forms of recapitalization and prerequisites for it.

To realize ROI, owners should move the cash out of the business and into his or her own pockets.

Traditionally there are two primary ways of producing ROI:

  • Developing a dividend stream that pays increasing amounts each year as the business grows.
  • Selling 100% of the business and reaping the capital gains.

This article discusses a third way: Funding a large personal investment portfolio by recapitalizing the business.  

Business ROI vs. Portfolio ROI

A savvy wealth manager knows that a diversified investment portfolio will offset business risk.

A recapitalization happens when a business changes its financial structure: adding debt, bringing on new investment or buying out old investors. Recapitalization, or “recap” for short, indicates a revision of a business’ capital structure.

More and more middle market companies are choosing a recap path as a means to distribute cash to their owners without an outright sale. Other uses of a recap include capitalizing an ESOP (Employee Stock Ownership Plan), buying out some of the shareholders and having money for expansion or acquisition.

There are several basic forms of recap. Each can usually be structured in a tax advantaged way, such as securing capital gain income and deferring taxes on retained ownership interests.

 Dividend Recap

 Minority Recap

 

 Majority Recap

 

A specialty lender provides a loan to the company which is distributed to the shareholders. Specialty lenders loan against cash flow on a multiple of EBITDA. Local banks loan against assets such as receivables and inventory. Cash flow loans almost always produce greater proceeds than asset based loans.

A private equity firm purchases a minority share of equity in the company.  By itself, this is a safe, debt free means of providing owner liquidity.  Combined with debt, it provides more money to distribute to the shareholders than a dividend recap.

A private equity firm purchases 51% or more of the business, using a combination of debt and equity investment.  This provides the most amount of money to be distributed.  Generally, a higher valuation is achieved as the investment is a “control premium.”

Recap Prerequisites

In order for a firm to qualify for a recap, the business should meet certain criteria:

Quality of Earnings. A stable, growing earnings history and good visibility of future earnings is necessary to support the debt and investor expectations. Evidence of quality earnings might be supported by long term contracts, billings to a large number of repeat customers, multiple ongoing billings to large customers, subscription business model and more. A history of lumpy up and down annual revenues may not qualify as there is not enough certainty that revenue and earnings are repeatable.

At least modest growth prospects.  A deteriorating business, with a declining history may find willing investors, but only at fire sale valuations. A steady business with few down years historically and an overall steady but low growth rate can attract quality investors. A business with a strong growth history and future will find many willing investors competing to win the transaction.

Size. The ideal candidate will have annual EBITDA of at least $3 million. Below this level, the number of private equity groups and lenders who will be interested dwindles significantly. Sokoloff & Co. recently took a firm to market with EBITDA in the $8-$10 million range. Nearly 100 PE firms reached out to us, we received 31 expressions of interest and received a number of excellent competing offers before selecting the winner.

Part 2 of this article will feature a case history comparing use of a recap vs. continuing to hold 100% of a growing business.

Stay tuned.

Sokoloff & Co. is a member of Axial. The firm advises buyers and sellers and has taken a number of its clients through the various transaction structures portrayed herein.

Learn More About Joining Axial

Request Information

Subscribe to Middle Market Review

Subscribe to Middle Market Review

Please provide valid email address

I want to receive:

Subscribe

Thanks for subscribing!